| Years | Leader |
| 1868 – 1868 | Max Wolff (reverend) |
| 1906 – 1920 | Elijah Isaac (cantor) |
| 1920 – 1930 | Isaac Ezra Elias (cantor) |
| 1926 – 1961 | Raymond Eleazer (rabbi) |
| August 1961 – late 1962 | Joir Adler (reverend – Orthodox) |
| April 1963 – end 1963 | Ferdinand Myron Isserman (rabbi – Reform) |
| February 1964 – late 1973 | David Benhayon (reverend, later rabbi) |
| January 1974 – mid 1977 | Solomon (Shlomo) Truzman (reverend, later rabbi) |
| April 1978 – late 1984 | David Hirshberg (reverend) |
| September 1985 – August 1986 | Mordechai Avtzon (rabbi – Chabad) |
| September 1986 – April 1990 | Meyer Bensoussan (rabbi – Orthodox) |
| April 1990 – June 1993 | Benzion Lapian (rabbi – Orthodox) |
| July 1993 – June 1997 | Shmuel Lopin (rabbi – Orthodox) |
| September 1997 – June 2003 | Yaakov Kermaier (rabbi – Orthodox) |
| September 2003 – November 2005 | David Zadok (rabbi – Orthodox) |
| November 2005 – October 2006 | Edward Jackson (rabbi – Orthodox) |
| October 2006 – February 2010 | Martin van den Bergh (rabbi – Orthodox) |
| March 2010 – October 2010 | Edward Jackson (rabbi – Orthodox) |
| October 2010 – present | Asher Oser (rabbi – Orthodox) |
